Melville, Herman, Read-Along

Moby-Dick Read-Along: Chapters 21-38

f8f13084-5301-4dd4-afdb-dcc0d7e9bd4f_zpsce6462f4This is week II of the Moby-Dick read-along hosted by Roof Beam Reader. We are now getting to the notoriously heavy/boring parts of the novel. However, I didn’t mind much the chapters on the different kinds of whales and the chapters that praise whaling. Ishamael’s descriptions of the whales may not be accurate, but I didn’t think those pages were meaningless.

I have wanted to be an entomologist since I was nine or ten years old. During most of my high school years, I remember feeling disappointed that invertebrates were hardly ever mentioned in my biology classes. Finally, the summer before my senior year, I got the opportunity to do an internship at the local museum of natural history. My project? Identifying spider wasps down to the species level. That summer, I spent hours peering through a microscope at the wing venation and abdominal setae of wasps, with only a hundred year old guide to help me. You read that right – a hundred year old guide! The pages were yellow and not held together by much.

I mention this experience by way of explaining why I valued the Moby-Dick chapters on cetology. I have never studied whales; I get seasick like no one I know. But, taxonomy is no easy task. Ishamael mentions the challenges taxonomists face in studying whales. The same is true for any other organism. In Melville’s time, the only way scientists could build cladograms was by studying the morphological similarities and differences between species. However, as Ishmael argues in the chapters on cetology, classification based on morphology alone is not always accurate.

“Thus, the sperm whale and the humpbacked whale, each has a hump; but there the similitude ceases. Then this same humpbacked whale and the Greenland whale, each of these has baleen; but there again the similitude ceases. And it is just the same with the other parts above mentioned. In various sorts of whales, they form such irregular combinations; or, in the case of any one of them detached, such an irregular isolation; as utterly to defy all general methodization formed upon such a basis. On this rock every one of the whale-naturalists has split.” 

My time at the museum and the evolutionary biology courses I took later in college gave me a great appreciation for the field of taxonomy, although this is not what I will be studying in graduate school. Ishmael is not a scientist. He admits to not understanding whale speciation like the naturalists he cites. Yet, I found the cetology passages to be valuable because of Ishmael’s commentary on taxonomy. I also learned a lot about the products that were produced from the different whales at a time when whaling was legal.

Enough about cetology. On to the other chapters of the reading.

Ahab is quite a memorable character. With a giant scar on his face and a peg leg, who can forget him. He is not interested in killing any whale. He wants to kill Moby-Dick, the white whale that dismembered him. Starbuck, the chief mate, may be ethically opposed to the killing of Moby-Dick, but Ahab is the captain. Like the whale he wants to destroy, Ahab is larger than life itself.

Ishmael gives the reader a very striking description of the three mates having dinner with the captain in his cabin.

“Over his ivory-inlaid table, Ahab presided like a mute, maned sea-lion on the white coral beach, surrounded by his war-like but still deferential cubs. In his own proper turn, each officer waited to be served. They were was little children before Ahab; and yet, in Ahab, there seemed not to lurk the smallest social arrogance. With one mind, their intent eyes all fastened upon the old man’s knife, as he carved the chief dish before him. I do not suppose that for the world they would have profaned that moment with the slightest observation, even upon so neutral a topic as the weather.”

The shipmates do not need to be told how to behave before their captain. They know that he is not a force to be reckoned with. He is respected (except maybe by the second mate, Stubb).

I could go on and on about the many observations I made in this week’s reading, but I will stop here. I am welcoming Melville’s digressions with open arms.

6 thoughts on “Moby-Dick Read-Along: Chapters 21-38”

  1. Great thoughts on the cetology chapter and I enjoyed reading about your entomology experience. For me Ishmael’s description of cetology signals a crucial difference between Melville’s pre-Darwinian world and ours. In Melville’s time, there was no real sense in which one classification system could be right or wrong – much like the Dewey Decimal System, it was a matter interpretation. Darwin’s genius showed that there was, in face, one correct classification scheme, that which describes common descent.

    Darwin’s discovery, and the other scientific advances that mark our time as different from Melville’s, speak to the different ways in which we and Melville view the world. We expect progress, while Melville, I think, was trapped in a world view in which progress was not assumed.

    1. I need to read On the Origin of Species at some point. I imagine that the difference between Darwin and Melville will become more clear if I do. Thank you for that insight.

      1. I’ve not read Origin, either. I recommend Richard Dawkins as a modern interpreter. Dawkins in The Blind Watchmaker (although it might be The Selfish Gene, I’m not completely sure) makes the argument that common descent gives an actual right-or-wrong answer to classification.

    1. I’m glad my comments helped you. Moby-Dick intimidated me, but I heard about the read-along and thought “Why not?”

      I will be reading Don Quixote after this, starting probably in the middle of July. That is another intimidating book. If you would like to join me, I can make Don Quixote into a read-along.

  2. I’m glad you’re enjoying the digression parts.I think if you can deal with them,you’re going to really like the book.
    For my part,I found the book really exciting at the beginning,but when Ishmael started digressing and talking about cetelogy,I lost all interest.I still read the book entirely without skipping any page,but I was not that engrossed into the book.
    It’s not that cetelogy is boring,but all my expectations from the book were shattered; I thought the book was [only] about an exciting adventure!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s